I chose this photo because Good Night Moon was always one of my favorite bed time stories and I distinctly recall Mr. Hurd, cigarette and all, appearing on the inside cover of my book. Although as a child I never paid much attention to the photo, I'm now glad to see that publishers are becoming more conscientious of the images they produce. It is true that publishers are concerned about liability, but I would like to think that they are also committed to protecting children from premature exposure to negative images.
Of course this is not an extreme case where censorship is indisputably necessary, and its true that many children remain unaffected by negative images such as these. Still, I think its better to keep the cigarette out on behalf of those children who's reading experience could be somehow tainted or compromised.

5 comments:
thats interesting, i didnt know they did that! at least its not too extreme
Good Night Moon was one of my favorite stories as well! I don't remember the picture of the author, but I agree that it was a good choice to remove the cigarrette in the photo.
I think that the publishers are being a little paranoid in this case, but I can see how it would be a liability.
I still feel that they should've worried about that since the beginning (when they first took the picture) intstead of changing it later.
Hmmm... this is a good debate. Clearly you remember the picture from your childhood so it left some type of impact; however, I also think we need adults to be good role models. I'm not sure what the answer is exactly.
Post a Comment